Restaurant closures, failures down under new restaurant health inspection system

You are currently viewing Restaurant closures, failures down under new restaurant health inspection system
KFC & A&W, 1321 N Dunlap Ave., Champaign The health department closed the restaurant Aug. 22 due to “gross unsanitary conditions” during its routine inspection. No details were provided in the report. On Thursday, November 29, 2018. photo by Darrell Hoemann/C-U Citizen Access

Since 2019, at least 63 Champaign-Urbana restaurants have failed and 19 have been temporarily closed down by public health officials under a new restaurant inspection system launched that year. 

On average, health inspectors failed 14 restaurants of 324 restaurants inspected each quarter between 2008 and 2017, according to an earlier analysis of public health department data by CU-CitizenAccess. Prior to the new system, health inspectors closed six restaurants and failed 18 restaurants between Jan. 1, 2018 to Oct. 31, 2018,

The new system started in January 2019 and uses a different evaluation system than its prior scoring system to pass or fail a restaurant. Sarah Michaels, environmental health program director, said the old scoring system was outdated. 

Before the new inspection system went into effect, a restaurant would be scored on a 100-point scale, with additional points deducted by the number of violations and the type of violations cited. A restaurant would fail with an adjusted score below 36 and would be shut down if it scored below 0. 

Both the new and old inspection systems are based on series of risk factors related to foodborne illnesses imposed by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) Model Food Code. The five risk factors inspectors look for are improper holding temperatures, inadequate cooking, contaminated equipment, food from unsafe sources and poor personal hygiene.

Under the new system, however, inspectors evaluate the risk factors into three types of violations – priority foundation, priority and core. Instead of a score, inspectors assign a color – green for passing, yellow for failing and red for closing.

Recent closure

On Oct. 26 of this year, Popeye’s on Bloomington Rd. was closed by the health department for running its drive-thru without a working hand sink. The violation demonstrates a risk factor for lack of personal hygiene. It falls under section 5-202.12 of the FDA food code, which states proper hand washing temperature must be at least 100°F.

Inspections are also based on The FDA Model Food Code’s five key public health interventions to protect consumer health. This includes demonstration of knowledge, employee health controls, controlling hands as a vehicle of contamination, time and temperature parameters for controlling pathogens, and consumer advisory.

The public can see the results from inspections in two ways. Each restaurant in Champaign-Urbana is required to post a color-coded placard — green for passing, yellow for failure and red for closure.  People can also go online to search for an inspection report via a database the health department has made public.

For years, health inspection results of restaurants and food establishments were only made available to the public by a formal records request to the health department. 

In 2011, CU-CitizenAccess began reporting on failed and closed restaurants, filing regular public records requests for failed inspections and reporting on the results. 

Months later, the health department started posting a list of restaurants that were inspected and if they needed to be reinspected but provided no further information.

Two years later, in mid-2014, public health officials began requiring restaurants within Champaign-Urbana city limits to post a color-coded placard of the inspection results. 

Restaurants and food establishments within Champaign County but outside city limits were not required to post a placard — owing to strong opposition from county officials.  That same year, the health department launched a public searchable database of food establishment health inspections. 

In McLean County, health inspections posted online are labeled a “yes” or “no” to indicate they have passed an inspection; full reports are not available on the McLean County Health Department’s website. Vermillion County’s health department website does not post any inspection reports or results. Instead, full inspection reports are accessed only through an information request. 

In Champaign County, however, there are some gaps in the system that make it unclear that a restaurant has failed an inspection.

For example, on Nov. 16, 2020, Garcia’s Pizza in a Pan received a green placard despite not having a certified food protection manager, a priority violation.

On Mar. 4, 2021, the restaurant received a yellow placard for the same risk factor, but it was indicated in the report the restaurant already had a yellow placard. This was never documented on the Champaign-Urbana Public Health District & Champaign County Health Department’s website.

“This was an issue with a Priority Violation that was not corrected within the time period,” Michaels explained. This is explained under section 3-2 B of the Food Program Enforcement Policy, which covers violations that cannot be corrected on sight but are not imminent health hazards.

Citizens can type the name of almost any restaurant in Champaign county into the Public Health District’s inspection report search engine. However, some reports are missing or the restaurant is not in the system at all. Pie’s The Limit, which closed in 2019 after failing its health inspection, cannot be found on the website. Other restaurants, such as Jurassic Grill, are still open for business but its reports are not listed.

Another gap in the system is some restaurants do have inspection reports listed upon search, but are missing failed reports. Ambar India, which was closed due to an unknown violation, was missing that specific report. Although, citizens can see other reports posted for this restaurant.

Leave a Reply